Call us what we are, toxic from the start
Can't pretend that I was in the dark
When you met my friends, didn't even try with them
I should've known right then

That you were jealous and possessive
So manipulatin'
Honestly, impressive
You had me participatin'

Back then, when I was runnin' out of your place
I said, "I never wanna see your face"
I meant I couldn't wait to see it again
We were toxic till the end
Uh-huh, 'cause even when I said it was over
You heard, "Baby, can you pull me in closer? "
You were plotting how to stay in my head
We were toxic till the end, end, end

I can forgive you for a lot of things
For not giving me back my Tiffany rings
I'll never forgive you for one thing, my dear
You wasted my prettiest years

Back then, when I was runnin' out of your place
I said, "I never wanna see your face"
I meant I couldn't wait to see it again