$3. 95 at the Walmart
This piece of brass opened my heart
And the door to everything that's in my name
All of my love, all my baggage
All of my calm, all my havoc
Everything was there for you to take

You were gonna move in when your lease ends
Hanging frames and painting kitchens
Is all we talked about
Ain't it funny how

I'm staring at a spare key
The one that used to be in your jeans
'Til you left it with no note in my mailbox
And I know you just wanna save me
From what you thought we never would be
But I would let you walk in and out of my life
And never change the locks
Now I'm staring at spare key
Do you really think you spared me?

From the hurt, from the damage
You stole my closure, girl, red handed
I couldn't read between the lines
And it's twisting like a knife

'Cause I'm staring at a spare key
The one that used to be in your jeans
'Til you left it with no note in my mailbox
And I know you just wanna save me
From what you thought we never would be
But I would let you walk in and out of my life
And never change the locks
Now I'm staring at spare key
Do you really think you spared me?

You were gonna move in when your lease ends
Hanging frames and painting kitchens
Is all we talked about
Ain't it funny how

I'm staring at a spare key
The one that used to be in your jeans
'Til you left it with no note in my mailbox
And I know you just wanna save me
From what you thought we never would be
But I would let you walk in and out of my life
And never change the locks
Now I'm staring at spare key
Do you really think you spared me?